08. Difference between Asian and European honeybees :

The European honeybee (Apis mellifera) and the Asian honeybee (Apis cerana) are both important species for pollination and honey production, but they have distinct differences in their biology, behavior, and, consequently, their management.

Differences Between European Honeybee (Apis mellifera) and Asian Honeybee (Apis cerana)

Here's a breakdown of their key distinctions:

1. Size and Appearance:

* European Honeybee: Generally larger (13-16 mm long) and typically have yellow abdominal banding with fine visible hairs all over the body. The pale bands on their abdomen are often variable in size and have indistinct edges.

* Asian Honeybee: Smaller (around 10 mm long) and less hairy. Their abdomen has pronounced, evenly spaced black/brown and yellow stripes. They also have a unique hindwing venation that can be used for identification.

2. Native Range and Distribution:

* European Honeybee: Native to Europe, Africa, and the Middle East, and has been introduced globally for beekeeping.

* Asian Honeybee: Native to South, Southeast, and East Asia, including parts of Australia (where it is considered an invasive species in some areas).

www.BeeGood.Today Beekeeping For Beginners Page 25 of 209

3. Colony Size and Nesting Habits:

* European Honeybee: Forms large colonies, typically ranging from 40,000 to 80,000 bees. They prefer to nest in dark, large cavities, such as hollow trees or house walls, and build multiple parallel combs.

* Asian Honeybee: Form smaller colonies, usually with a few thousand bees (e.g., 6,000 to 7,000 individuals). They also build multiple combs in dark cavities, but can readily nest in smaller, human-created spaces, such as letterboxes, pot plants, and wall cavities, often near the ground.

4. Swarming and Absconding Behaviour:

* European Honeybee: Swarms typically once or twice a year, depending on factors like health and resources.

* Asian Honeybee: Swarm and abscond (abandon the hive entirely) much more frequently, sometimes 6-8 times a year. This is a significant factor in their management.

5. Temperament and Defensiveness:

* European Honeybee: Generally considered more docile and placid, stinging primarily when threatened or provoked.

* Asian Honeybee: Can be more defensive and are known to sting readily, though some regional variations (e.g., A. cerana japonica) may be more docile. They may abscond when exposed to smoke, which is often used to calm European bees.

6. Pest and Disease Resistance:

* European Honeybee: Highly susceptible to Varroa mites (Varroa destructor), which can decimate colonies if left untreated.

* Asian Honeybee: Co-evolved with Varroa mites (Varroa jacobsoni and V. destructor) and often exhibits natural resistance mechanisms, such as hygienic

www.BeeGood.Today Beekeeping For Beginners Page 26 of 209

behaviour (removing infested brood) and grooming. They are the primary host for these mites.

7. Honey Production:

* European Honeybee: Known for higher honey production per colony due to their larger colony size and foraging efficiency.

* Asian Honeybee: Produces less honey per harvest compared to European Honeybees.

Differences in Hive Management

The contrasting characteristics of these two species necessitate different beekeeping approaches:

1. Hive Size and Type:

* European Honeybee: Commonly kept in standardized larger hive boxes like the Langstroth hive, which accommodates their large colony size and allows for easy frame manipulation.

* Asian Honeybee: Requires smaller hive boxes, often modified versions of Langstroth hives, or traditional regional hives (e.g., "kahon-style" hives, multi-chambered wooden boxes, log hives). The internal volume typically ranges from 20 to 25 litres.

2. Swarm Control and Absconding Prevention:

* European Honeybee: Beekeepers actively manage colonies to prevent or minimize swarming through techniques like splitting hives, providing ample space, and requeening.

* Asian Honeybee: Due to their frequent swarming and absconding tendencies, management focuses on providing attractive bait hives to capture swarms and understanding the triggers for absconding (e.g., lack of forage, pest pressure, disturbance). Smoke is often avoided during manipulation as it can trigger absconding.

3. Pest and Disease Management:

* European Honeybee: Requires active monitoring and treatment for Varroa mites and other common diseases. Integrated Pest Management (IPM) strategies are crucial.

* Asian Honeybee: Their natural resistance to Varroa mites means that chemical treatments may be less frequently needed or absent in some traditional beekeeping practices. However, they can still be vectors for diseases that affect A. mellifera.

4. Temperament and Handling:

* European Honeybee: Beekeepers use smoke to calm bees before opening hives and wear protective gear.

* Asian Honeybee: More protective gear is often recommended due to their more defensive nature. Gentle manipulation is critical, and the use of smoke is limited or avoided to prevent absconding.

5. Honey Harvesting:

* European Honeybee: Larger honey harvests are the norm, often involving multiple supers (boxes where honey is stored).

* Asian Honeybee: Honey harvests are smaller and more frequent.

6. Queen Rearing:

* European Honeybee: Standardized queen-rearing techniques are widely practised.

* Asian Honeybee: Queen rearing techniques may need to be adapted due to differences in their queen cell development and acceptance, with specific practices like "wet grafting" and ensuring queenless, populous cell-builder colonies.